Free packaging audit · before a redesign

A packaging redesign costs money. A second opinion doesn’t

What to keep on your pack, what to strengthen and in what order — checked against the shelf of your category. Send a photo and get a 3-page report by email in 30–40 minutes.

An agency is doing your redesign? Check their work — also free.

Check my pack → Free · no sales calls before the report · we never publish your artwork
1,564world benchmarks
from 66 countries
414redesigns
with known sales outcome
68category shelves
in 4 countries
Why it matters

Shoppers don’t read packaging.
They scan it

Design gets judged on a monitor, up close, by people who know what it says. Shoppers see the pack from five feet away among dozens of neighbors — or as a thumbnail in search results. That’s a different pack.

2–3 things

is what a shopper takes away from a pack in a couple of seconds at the shelf. The audit shows which ones they will see on yours — and whether they’re the right ones.

150 px

thumbnail size in marketplace search results. Faces and details disappear; what’s left is the silhouette, color and a couple of big words.

When people come for an audit

Before a decision that costs money

The audit doesn’t replace your agency or argue with it. It brings numbers where people usually argue about taste — to the owner, the agency or yourself. Whoever designs for you.

Planning a redesign

Find out what on the pack must not be touched and what needs strengthening. In our redesign base, when a brand removed its recognizable element, one in three ended with a sales drop — 10 of 30. Where the element was kept — none of 97.

Redesign case base, mostly US and UK mass market.

An agency is doing the redesign

Even if we’re not your designers, check the work for free. Send the options — up to 5 files: we’ll show which one reads better from the shelf and as a thumbnail, and what was kept of the recognizable. In scores, not opinions.

Entering a new chain or marketplace

Your pack on the real shelf of your category and as a 150 px thumbnail next to search-result cards of your category.

Artwork before print

Fixing artwork before the print run is cheaper than after.

Sales dropped

Check whether the pack is the problem: does it stand out among neighbors, and can people find it from a description?

You need arguments

A report with scores out of 100 and three steps you can put on the owner’s desk or attach to a design brief.

deepUP model

Not a designer’s opinion. A benchmark base and measurements

We compare every pack not with “good taste” but with the real shelf of its category and with world benchmarks: award winners and packs that sell well. Behind the model is a base our agency collected and tagged with one method.

68category shelves in 4 countries — each with 10+ real packs with dimensions, so yours stands among neighbors at the right scale
7,025marketplace hero images — to see how search results look in your category
414redesigns with a known outcome in sales: what was kept, what changed and how it ended
1,564world benchmarks from 66 countries, tagged with one method: we look for strong moves outside your category too

The gaze model is checked against published eye-tracking studies: 91 people looking at 158 packs (Orquin), 25 people looking at 972 product cards (SalECI). It is a forecast, not a recording of people.

Five areas of assessment

What we check

Five areas, the same scoring rules for every pack. Each gets a score out of 100 and one of three labels: “already works” (75+), “room to grow” (50–74), “needs attention” (below 50).

01

Meaning and brand

Does the pack say what you want to say, and is the name memorable?

02

Reading order

Does the eye meet the most important words first, in a clear order?

03

Clear what’s inside

Will a stranger understand what it is in a couple of seconds?

04

Different from neighbors

Is there something only you have, so people find you again?

We compare with your shelf neighbors: what everyone has, and what only you have.

05

Shelf and online

Does the pack work from a few steps away and as a small photo in search results?

How the audit runs

Four steps. The same as in the report

We tag every element

We outline every word, image and color block on the front. We read your website to understand what you want to say.

We predict where the eye lands

A computer model predicts what the eye notices in the first second and within 3 seconds. A simulation, not a recording of people.

Model shoppers read the pack

Five shopper profiles from your market and one who sees the pack for the first time, without knowing your brand. These are computer models, not a survey. Plus a “buy me…” test: from a shopper’s phrase, the model looks for your pack on the shelf.

We compare with the shelf

Your pack among 10+ category neighbors at real scale. Your category or market isn’t built yet? We build its shelf first.

Before sending, two independent checkers review the report — also models: one checks the facts, the other checks clarity.

Honest rules

What we look at. And what we don’t

Taste is an unreliable judge of sales. We removed everything that can’t be checked against shopper behavior.

✓We look at

  • What gets noticed in the first secondand whether the name, product type and your difference are there
  • Whether it’s clear what’s inside and how you differadjusted for whether you’re a leader or a newcomer
  • Your pack among neighborsthe real category shelf and “lookalikes” — same price and format
  • Whether people find you from a description“get me the cookies in the blue pack with a fox” — is it clearly you
  • The marketplace thumbnailconsidering how search-result cards look in your category

✕We don’t look at

  • “Pretty or not”a beautiful pack nobody finds sells worse than a clear one
  • Fashion for its own sakea trend counts only if it creates difference in your category
  • Back panel and ingredientswe don’t check them. Mandatory front-of-pack statements — yes, by the rules of your market. This is not a legal opinion
  • A single opinionevery conclusion rests on a measurement, the base or a test — the source is shown in the report
  • A finished redesignwe give directions and a “how to check” for each, we don’t design it for you
Comparison

Why not just “ask a designer”

Designer’s opinionHeat-map serviceEye-tracking and focus groupsdeepUP Audit
What gets noticed in the first secondby eyeyesyes, with peoplemodel forecast checked against published eye-tracking
Knows your category and shelfif they worked with itnoif a shelf was built68 shelves in 4 countries, real dimensions; not yours? we build it for your request
Difference from competitors in numbersnonopartlyhow many neighbors do the same
“Will they find it from a description” testnonorarelyyes
Marketplace thumbnail for your category’s search resultssometimesgeneric, not category-specificnoyes
What to do next“redo it”a map without conclusionsa report of dozens of slides3 steps + how to check
Time and pricedays · dependsminutes · subscriptionweeks · expensive30–40 minutes · free
Sample report

Three pages about one pack

Illustrative example: the brand, pack and numbers are made up — so you see the method, not someone else’s design. The report you get is built the same way: 3 pages, five areas, three steps.

PACKAGING AUDIT
MARKET: USAILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE1 / 3
OVSEA · “APPLE & CINNAMON” GRANOLA · 10.6 OZ
Apple with cinnamon, the granola window and your name already reach the shopper.
STEPS IN ORDER

“No added sugar” on the front

“Granola” — bigger

One cue of your own for the range

WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY

Your website in our words: granola with no added sugar, sweet from baked apples; baked in small batches; four flavors.

WHAT THE SHOPPER READS

Sweet granola with apple and cinnamon — for breakfast yogurt.

How model shoppers described it — computer models of shoppers, not a survey.

Did we get your message right? We built it from your website and the pack itself.
ALREADY WORKSKeep
ROOM TO GROWIn order
4of5model shoppers named the flavor right away

01 The flavor reads at first glance

The apple slice and cinnamon stick sit above the name, so the flavor is clear before any reading. Keep them in any update.

1st secondthe granola window gets noticed first

02 The window shows what’s inside

Big clusters are visible before any word. The shopper instantly gets a crunchy breakfast, not oatmeal.

5of5read the name right the first time

03 The name is short and memorable

All model shoppers read “Ovsea” correctly and could repeat it. A name like that is easy to say in “get me…”.

6of11neighbors say “no added sugar” on the front

04 Say “no added sugar” on the front

On the website it’s the main argument, but it’s not on the pack yet. Model shoppers decided the granola is sweet, with honey.

2of5called it muesli, not granola

05 Make “granola” bigger

The word “granola” is one of the smallest on the front. Without it, crunchy granola is easy to mistake for muesli.

8of11neighbors also show granola in a window

06 Find a detail that’s only yours

The window explains what’s inside, but almost everyone has one. To be found again, you need your own cue across all 4 flavors.

Illustrative example · the pack is drawn
WHY IT MATTERS

At the shelf a shopper gives a pack a couple of seconds and takes away two or three things. The report shows which ones they’ll see on yours — and whether they’re the right ones.

HOW A MODEL SHOPPER DESCRIBED THE PACK

“A bag with a clear window, big granola clusters inside, an apple slice and a cinnamon stick above the window, “Ovsea” in large letters.”

They saw only the pack — as from two steps away and as a small search photo — and didn’t know your brand.
A computer model predicts where the eye lands — a forecast, not a recording of people. Model shoppers, not a survey: one sees the pack for the first time, plus five granola shopper profiles. “Get me…” test: three requests on a model shelf. Shelf: your pack and 11 illustrative neighbors.
Illustrative example · the pack is drawndeepUP
12Illustrative example
  1. 1Pack as a map: left — what already works, right — where to grow
  2. 2What you want to say — and what the shopper read
PACKAGING AUDIT
OVSEAILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE2 / 3
What the shopper sees and how we measured
What gets noticed in the first second
Five areas
SCORE OUT OF 100
Color — where the eye lingers in the first 3 seconds. Numbers — what’s likely noticed in the first second.
  • 1Apple & Cinnamon
  • 2Granola window
  • 3“Ovsea”

Numbers mark spots likely to be noticed, not one person’s path.

Maybe“Baked Granola”, “Big crunchy clusters”

Unlikely“10.6 oz”, small print at the bottom of the front

WHAT IT MEANS FOR YOU

Most likely noticed: the flavor, the granola window and the name “Ovsea”. Not on the pack yet: “no added sugar” and a cue that’s only yours.

This is a simulation: the model predicts what a shopper is more likely to notice on this pack. A forecast, not a recording of people.

Meaning and brand

61

Does the pack say what you want to say, and is the name memorable?

room to grow

Reading order

77

Does the eye meet the most important words first, in a clear order?

already works

Clear what’s inside

66

Will a stranger understand what it is in a couple of seconds?

room to grow

Different from neighbors

44

Is there something only you have, so people find you again?

needs attention

Shelf and online

58

Does the pack work from a few steps away and as a small photo in search results?

room to grow
75 and above: already works50–74: room to growbelow 50: needs attention

“Meaning and brand” — room to grow: the name and flavor land, but the website’s main argument isn’t on the front yet.

“Shelf and online”: in the small search photo the flavor reads, the word “granola” doesn’t.

HOW WE MEASUREDFour steps, the same for every pack
1

We tag every element

We outline every word, image and color block on the front.

2

We predict where the eye lands

A computer model predicts what the eye notices first.

3

Model shoppers read the pack

Five profiles and one who sees the pack for the first time: models, not a survey.

4

We compare with the shelf

Your pack next to 11 granolas at the right scale.

Behind the report — a tagged base of real packaging

Tagged base

We split every front into zones and compare with real shelves.

Gaze model

Checked against published eye-tracking studies.

For your category

A granola shelf, five shopper profiles and the “get me…” test.

Statements by market rules

Front checked against FDA labeling rules (21 CFR 101); this is not a legal opinion.

34Illustrative example
  1. 3What the eye notices in the first second. A simulation, not a recording of people
  2. 4Five areas: a score out of 100 and a plain explanation for each
PACKAGING AUDIT
OVSEAILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE3 / 3
The pack among neighbors
Almost everyone here has a granola window. A big “no sugar” and your own cue help people find the pack.
Asked for “granola with no sugar, with apple” — the model chose Neighbor 4
From a description without the name, yours was found on the second try — by the apple slice
Neighbor 1
Neighbor 2
Neighbor 3
Neighbor 4
Neighbor 5
Ovsea · Yours
Neighbor 6
Neighbor 7
Neighbor 8
Neighbor 9
Neighbor 10
Neighbor 11
“No sugar” on the front: 6 of 11Yours — noGranola window: 8 of 11, and yoursIllustrative neighbors · pack proportions approximate

What to do

THREE STEPS IN ORDER
ON THE NEXT ARTWORK

Say “no added sugar” on the front

Make “no added sugar” the second-largest line, right under the flavor. Check the claim against the ingredients before print.

How to checkSomeone sees the pack for 3 seconds and says “no sugar”, not “sweet, with honey”.
SAME ARTWORK

Make “granola” bigger

Move the word “granola” up to the name: it must read from two steps away and in a small search photo.

How to checkIn a thumbnail-size photo the word “granola” reads, and nobody calls the pack muesli.
FOR ALL 4 FLAVORS

One cue — only yours

Pick one cue for the whole range: the window shape, a color band or a mark. Keep the apple and cinnamon — they work.

How to checkA friend describes the pack without the name, it gets found among five other granolas, and the description doesn’t fit the neighbors.

Mandatory statements: what we checked on the front

RULEON THE PACKRESULT
Statement of identity says what the product is“Baked Granola” — small, under the flavorpresent; bigger — step 2
Net quantity is stated“10.6 oz” at the bottom of the frontpresent
Voluntary claims are not misleading“Big crunchy clusters”; “no added sugar” will appear after step 1check against ingredients before print
Ingredients, Nutrition Facts, allergens, manufacturerback panel not in the photonot checked

Checked against FDA labeling rules (21 CFR 101). This is not a legal opinion. Show the artwork to a labeling specialist before print.

Let’s go through it together: free, 30 minutes
56Illustrative example
  1. 5The pack among category neighbors and the “get me…” test
  2. 6Three steps, each with how to check. Plus mandatory statements
Get my report
What arrives by email

What the report includes

The report is written for the owner and the marketer, not the designer: no jargon, with a direct answer to your question.

  • 01
    What already works — in one line, and three steps to start withon page one, around your pack: left — what to keep, right — where to grow
  • 02
    Five areas scored out of 100and a plain explanation of each
  • 03
    What the eye notices firstsimulation: what’s likely noticed in the first second and within 3 seconds
  • 04
    Your pack among neighborsthe real shelf of your category at the right scale, and the “get me…” test
  • 05
    Three steps, in ordereach with a “how to check”, plus mandatory front-of-pack statements by the rules of your market
Free · 2 minutes

Check your packaging

A phone photo, a render or pre-print artwork all work.

  1. Upload the front of the packstraight on, no glare; several flavors are fine
  2. Answer 2 questionswhere you sell and what you need — we read the rest from the pack
  3. Sign in or create a free accountwith a work email, confirmed once — 2 free audits per account
  4. Get a 3-page report by email30–40 minutes for a known category, up to 3 hours for a new one
  5. Go through it with an experta free 30-minute call — if you want one
Step 1 of 2

The model reads the brand, the category and what the pack says by itself. What it can’t read, a shopper won’t notice either — and that goes into the report.

Audits come with a free deepUP account: 2 free audits, a confirmed work email, your reports in one place.

personal Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook won’t work — the audit is for companies
Who’s behind the audit

deepUP Team

We build brands and packaging for food and beverage, pharma and B2B companies. The audit method was built by the deepUP team on our practice and a base of packaging from all over the world. Behind it is 20+ years of team experience in brand strategy and design. Where we work: New York — North America, Buenos Aires — Latin America, Paris — Europe.

Clients include Mondelēz International, Volvo Trucks and Tetra Pak.

Want to see our brand and packaging work? We share cases from your category on request.

FAQ

Quick answers

Is it really free? What’s the catch?

Free and with no obligation. It pays off for us when you see how we think: some people who get a report come to us for a redesign or a brand strategy. If you don’t — you still keep an honest review.

Why a work email and confirmation?

You create a free account with a work email and confirm it once by a link — so audits go to companies, not bots. We don’t accept personal mailboxes (Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook and the like) — the audit is for companies. Free: 2 audits per account and up to 4 per company. Need more — press “Get more audits” in your account, or write to us through the contact form below.

Who does the audit — an AI?

Yes, the report is assembled by the deepUP system: a computer gaze model, model shoppers (not a survey of people) and a comparison with your category shelf. The method, the base and the scoring rules are ours — built by people at the agency. Before sending, two independent checkers review the report, also models: one checks facts, the other clarity. You can discuss the findings on a free call with a deepUP expert.

Is this eye-tracking? How far can I trust it?

No, it’s not a recording of people’s gaze. The gaze model is a forecast checked against published eye-tracking studies. It’s good at guessing what gets noticed first. It doesn’t measure meaning and choice — that’s why model shoppers and the “get me…” test sit next to it. If the decision is worth millions, we recommend a live test after the audit — we’ll suggest which one.

How long does it take?

If your category’s shelf is already built for your market — usually 30–40 minutes. If not, we first build and analyze that shelf: up to 3 hours. On days with more requests than we can handle well — up to two business days, and we’ll let you know.

Another agency is doing our redesign. Why do we need you?

Like a doctor’s second opinion: the agency designs, we check against data. The audit shows what recognizable elements were kept and what’s visible on the shelf and in the thumbnail — and gives you arguments for a conversation with the agency, not a reason to fight. Send the agency’s options — we’ll compare what was kept and what was lost. It’s free and commits you to nothing.

Does the audit work for a brand-new brand?

The audit is built for packaging that already exists — on shelf or as artwork. If the brand is just being created, send the pre-print artwork: we’ll check how it stands among neighbors. For building a brand from scratch we do strategy, positioning and naming.

My artwork isn’t on sale yet. Is it safe?

Yes. Only the system and deepUP experts see the files; we don’t publish them or use them in our portfolio without your written permission. NDA on request. Fixing artwork before the print run is cheaper than after — and a pre-print audit is exactly that moment.

Which markets and categories do you cover?

Shelves already built: 16 categories for Canada, 4 for the US and 2 for Argentina — from cookies, chips and cheese to coffee, vitamins and pet food — with real packs at real scale. Our world benchmarks come from 66 countries, and the US is the largest share. Your category or market isn’t built yet? Send the pack anyway: we build its shelf for your market before the audit — that’s the “up to 3 hours” case. Front-of-pack statements are checked against your market’s rules (FDA in the US, CFIA in Canada). This is not a legal opinion.

What happens after the report?

Nothing pushy. The report includes an invitation to a 30-minute review with an expert — on growth areas and your questions. If you need a redesign or a brand strategy, we’ll tell you how we work. Sometimes we’ll send useful materials on packaging design — unsubscribe in one click.

Beyond the pack

Tell us about a brand project

Strategy, positioning, naming or a portfolio that needs order. A partner of deepUP replies within one business day.

Before you change your packaging,
find out what in it already works.

Free packaging audit on the deepUP model: what to keep, what to strengthen and three steps to start. 3-page report by email.

Check my pack →